The Sushi FAQ Logo
 

Sushi Questions Answered
Soy Sauce Replacement

Q: I am a sashimi addict but just learned I am allergic to soy. So much so that I can't even have soy sauce despite the fermentation. After research and recipe trial and error, I was advised that a palatable substitute is Chinese black vinegar/black rice vinegar, or the British condiment Marmite mixed with mushroom broth. Do you have any advice or do you know of any product that tastes similar to soy sauce, minus the soy? - Brett G.

The only thing that I have heard of people replacing soy sauce with is Worcestershire sauce, which is becoming more popular in China due to their supposed similarities. I'm not personally sure just how similar they are (I like them both, but I've never thought to try a similarity test). Worcestershire sauce is actually based on the Vietnamese 'nuoc man' which is fish based (Worcestershire sauce has fish, sardine I believe, as an ingredient), so theoretically I could see how it might go with sushi. The predominant property of soy sauce is it's saltiness, but it also adds a depth of flavor, a meatiness known as umami to foods. Worcestershire sauce may actually do the same, so who knows.... I have never tried to use it as a replacement for soy sauce, but since some folks around the world do, hey... you never know! I'd be curious to hear what you think. Other than that, I'm sorry, I can't think of anything else that has ever come up as a replacement. There are actually other 'flavorings' such a product called Maagi (which can be hard to find in the US) that are yeast based (a natural source of MSG) that might do the trick, but they are much stronger in flavor so should be used sparingly. I put it in/on meats, eggs, and almost every stir fry that I make and it's a excellent product and definitely adds a tremendous depth of umami flavor to a dish.
 

                                                                          


Copyright© 2000 - 2009 The Sushi FAQ (sushifaq.com)